Journal article

Publication year: 2002

Pages: 337-370

Journal: The Astrophysical Journal: Supplement Series

Volume number: 138

Issue number: 2

ISSN: 0067-0049

eISSN: 1538-4365

Open access status: Green

DOI Link: https://doi.org/10.1086/323388

Publisher: American Astronomical Society

Abstract: 

We have measured the resonance strengths and energies for dielectronic recombination (DR) of Fe XX forming Fe XIX via N = 2 --> N' = 2 (DeltaN = 0) core excitations. We have also calculated the DR resonance strengths and energies using the AUTOSTRUCTURE, Hebrew University Lawrence Livermore Atomic Code (HULLAC), Multiconfiguration Dirac-Fock (MCDF), and R-matrix methods, four different state-of-the-art theoretical techniques. On average the theoretical resonance strengths agree to within less than or similar to10% with experiment. The AUTOSTRUCTURE, MCDF, and R-matrix results are in better agreement with experiment than are the HULLAC results. However, in all cases the 1 sigma standard deviation for the ratios of the theoretical-to-experimental resonance strengths is greater than or similar to30%, which is significantly larger than the estimated relative experimental uncertainty of less than or similar to10%. This suggests that similar errors exist in the calculated level populations and line emission spectrum of the recombined ion. We confirm that theoretical methods based on inverse-photoionization calculations (e.g., undamped R-matrix methods) will severely overestimate the strength of the DR process unless they include the effects of radiation damping. We also find that the coupling between the DR and radiative recombination (RR) channels is small.

Below 2 eV the theoretical resonance energies can be up to approximate to30% larger than experiment. This is larger than the estimated uncertainty in the experimental energy scale (less than or similar to0.5% below approximate to25 eV and less than or similar to0.2% for higher energies) and is attributed to uncertainties in the calculations. These discrepancies makes DR of Fe XX an excellent case for testing atomic structure calculations of ions with partially filled shells. Above 2 eV, agreement between the theoretical and measured energies improves dramatically with the AUTOSTRUCTURE and MCDF results falling within 2% of experiment, the R-matrix results within 3%, and HULLAC within 5%. Agreement for all four calculations improves as the resonance energy increases.

We have used our experimental and theoretical results to produce Maxwellian-averaged rate coefficients for DeltaN = 0 DR of Fe XX. For k(B)T(e) greater than or similar to 1 eV, which includes the predicted formation temperatures for Fe XX in an optically thin, low-density photoionized plasma with cosmic abundances, the experimental and theoretical results agree to better than approximate to15%. This is within the total estimated experimental uncertainty limits of less than or similar to20%. Agreement below approximate to1 eV is difficult to quantify due to current theoretical and experimental limitations. Agreement with previously published LS-coupling rate coefficients is poor, particularly for k(B)T(e) less than or similar to80 eV. This is attributed to errors in the resonance energies of these calculations as well as the omission of DR via 2p(1/2) - 2p(3/2) core excitations. We have also used our R-matrix results, topped off using AUTOSTRUCTURE for RR into J greater than or equal to 25 levels, to calculate the rate coefficient for RR of Fe XX. Our RR results are in good agreement with previously published calculations. We find that for temperatures as low as k(B)T(e) approximate to10(-3) eV, DR still dominates over RR for this system.

Harvard Citation style: Savin, D., Behar, E., Kahn, S., Gwinner, G., Saghiri, A., Schmitt, M., et al. (2002) Dielectronic Recombination (via N = 2 → N' = 2 Core Excitations) and Radiative Recombination of Fe XX: Laboratory Measurements and Theoretical Calculations, The Astrophysical Journal: Supplement Series, 138(2), pp. 337-370. https://doi.org/10.1086/323388

APA Citation style: Savin, D., Behar, E., Kahn, S., Gwinner, G., Saghiri, A., Schmitt, M., Grieser, M., Repnow, R., Schwalm, D., Wolf, A., Bartsch, T., Müller, A., Schippers, S., Badnell, N., Chen, M., & Gorczyca, T. (2002). Dielectronic Recombination (via N = 2 → N' = 2 Core Excitations) and Radiative Recombination of Fe XX: Laboratory Measurements and Theoretical Calculations. The Astrophysical Journal: Supplement Series. 138(2), 337-370. https://doi.org/10.1086/323388